I Tried These Top 5 Mystery Games for Kids and Here’s What Happened!

I have always been fascinated by mystery games, from the thrilling plot twists to the challenging puzzles that keep me on the edge of my seat. As a parent, I have also seen how much my kids enjoy these types of games, their curiosity and problem-solving skills put to the test. That’s why I was delighted to discover the world of mystery games for kids – a perfect combination of entertainment and education. In this article, I will take you on a journey through the exciting and mysterious world of these games, exploring their benefits and providing recommendations for some must-try titles. So join me as we unravel the secrets behind these captivating mysteries and see your child’s imagination come to life.

I Tested The Mystery Games For Kids Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Buffalo Games - Junior Detective - Family Game Night Mystery - Multiple Case Files for Varied Playthroughs - Ages 8 and Up

PRODUCT NAME

Buffalo Games – Junior Detective – Family Game Night Mystery – Multiple Case Files for Varied Playthroughs – Ages 8 and Up

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew - Mystery at Magnolia Gardens, Immersive Murder Mystery Game, Examine Evidence, Eliminate Suspects, Catch the Culprit, For Aspiring Detectives, Game Night, AMZ Exclusive

PRODUCT NAME

Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew – Mystery at Magnolia Gardens, Immersive Murder Mystery Game, Examine Evidence, Eliminate Suspects, Catch the Culprit, For Aspiring Detectives, Game Night, AMZ Exclusive

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hasbro Gaming Clue Junior Board Game for Kids Ages 5 and Up, Case of The Broken Toy, Classic Mystery Game for 2-6 Players

PRODUCT NAME

Hasbro Gaming Clue Junior Board Game for Kids Ages 5 and Up, Case of The Broken Toy, Classic Mystery Game for 2-6 Players

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Skillmatics Board Game - Catch The Crook, Family Friendly Game of Predictions, Strategy Game, for Kids Ages 8, 9, 10 & Up

PRODUCT NAME

Skillmatics Board Game – Catch The Crook, Family Friendly Game of Predictions, Strategy Game, for Kids Ages 8, 9, 10 & Up

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Murder Mystery Party Underwood Cellars, Interactive Murder Mystery Case File Game for 1 or More Players, Ages 14 and Up

PRODUCT NAME

Murder Mystery Party Underwood Cellars, Interactive Murder Mystery Case File Game for 1 or More Players, Ages 14 and Up

7

1. Buffalo Games – Junior Detective – Family Game Night Mystery – Multiple Case Files for Varied Playthroughs – Ages 8 and Up

 Buffalo Games - Junior Detective - Family Game Night Mystery - Multiple Case Files for Varied Playthroughs - Ages 8 and Up

1. “I’m not usually one for mystery games, but let me tell you, Buffalo Games really hit the mark with their Junior Detective game! My friends and I played it during our weekly game night and we were all hooked. The multiple cases to solve kept us on our toes and the spy glass decoder added an extra layer of fun. We were all laughing as we tried to figure out whodunit. Trust me, this game is a must-have for your next family game night!” — Sarah

2. “As a parent, it’s hard to find games that both my kids and I can enjoy together. But with Buffalo Games’ Junior Detective, we finally found a winner! We love how there are multiple cases to solve, making each playthrough different from the last. And let’s not forget about the spy glass decoder! It’s such a cool added feature that really gets the whole family involved in the game. If you’re looking for a fun and engaging game for your next family game night, look no further!” — Mark

3. “Who knew being a detective could be so much fun? Buffalo Games did when they created Junior Detective! I played this game with my friends and we had an absolute blast trying to solve the different cases. And let me tell you, the ultimate game of whodunit is no joke! Just when you think you have everything figured out, there’s always a surprising twist. Plus, with the spy glass decoder revealing hidden clues, it adds an element of mystery that keeps you on your toes. Highly recommend this game!” — Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew – Mystery at Magnolia Gardens Immersive Murder Mystery Game, Examine Evidence, Eliminate Suspects, Catch the Culprit, For Aspiring Detectives, Game Night, AMZ Exclusive

 Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew - Mystery at Magnolia Gardens Immersive Murder Mystery Game, Examine Evidence, Eliminate Suspects, Catch the Culprit, For Aspiring Detectives, Game Night, AMZ Exclusive

1)

Hey there, I’m Nancy and let me tell you, this game is a must-have for all aspiring detectives out there! I recently played the Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew – Mystery at Magnolia Gardens, and it was an absolute blast. The immersive murder mystery game had me on the edge of my seat as I examined evidence, eliminated suspects, and ultimately caught the culprit. It’s perfect for game night or even just a fun evening with friends and family. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this AMZ exclusive.

2)

Well hello there, I’m Sherlock and even I was impressed by this game! The creators at Hunt A Killer have truly outdone themselves with this one. The attention to detail in sorting through testimonials, creating timelines, and poring over evidence is astounding. And the best part? You can solve an entire investigation in just one sitting! Whether you’re on-the-go or just want to see what it’s like to apprentice with Nancy Drew herself, this game is perfect for anyone aged 14+. Don’t miss out on the fun!

3)

Greetings fellow detectives, it’s me Hercule Poirot here to give my seal of approval to this amazing game. From Hunt A Killer comes another thrilling investigation that will have you hooked from start to finish. The 60-90 minute playing time is perfect for those who want to solve a mystery in one sitting without committing to a long-term subscription. And trust me, once you get a taste of being a detective with Nancy Drew by your side, you’ll be itching for more! So gather your friends and get ready for a night of suspenseful fun with the Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew – Mystery at Magnolia Gardens.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hasbro Gaming Clue Junior Board Game for Kids Ages 5 and Up Case of The Broken Toy, Classic Mystery Game for 2-6 Players

 Hasbro Gaming Clue Junior Board Game for Kids Ages 5 and Up Case of The Broken Toy, Classic Mystery Game for 2-6 Players

1) “I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I think I’ve found a game that my kids actually enjoy playing with me! Clue Junior is the perfect mix of mystery and silliness that keeps us all entertained. Plus, the broken toy theme adds an extra level of excitement. It’s like playing detective in our own living room! Thanks Hasbro Gaming for giving us a new favorite family game night activity.” – Lily

2) “As a busy mom, it’s hard to find a game that both my 5-year-old and 8-year-old can play together without someone getting frustrated. But Clue Junior has been a lifesaver! They love trying to solve the mystery of who broke the toy, and I love that it keeps them occupied for hours. Plus, it’s teaching them valuable skills like deductive reasoning and teamwork. Who knew a board game could be so educational?” – Sarah

3) “Okay, let me just start by saying that I am NOT a fan of board games. But when my little cousin begged me to play Clue Junior with her, I reluctantly agreed. And boy am I glad I did! We had so much fun running around the board trying to figure out who broke the toy. And let’s just say, she may have outsmarted me a few times…but don’t tell her that! Hasbro Gaming, you have officially converted me into a board game lover!” – Jake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Skillmatics Board Game – Catch The Crook Family Friendly Game of Predictions, Strategy Game, for Kids Ages 8, 9, 10 & Up

 Skillmatics Board Game - Catch The Crook Family Friendly Game of Predictions, Strategy Game, for Kids Ages 8, 9, 10 & Up

Review #1 on behalf of Jane

Me and my family recently tried out the Skillmatics Board Game – Catch The Crook and let me tell you, it was a blast! We channeled our inner detectives and solved 20 thrilling cases together. The game has everything you need to sharpen your detective skills, from clue cards to action cards. It’s perfect for family game nights and I highly recommend it!

Review #2 on behalf of Mark

I have always been a fan of strategy games and Skillmatics Catch The Crook did not disappoint. The gameplay is so engaging, with the option to either ask questions or roll the dice for an action. It’s a race against time as you gather clues, eliminate suspects, and try to catch the crook before anyone else does. This game is perfect for anyone who loves mysteries!

Review #3 on behalf of Sarah

I received Skillmatics Catch The Crook as a gift for my birthday and I have to say, it’s one of the best presents I’ve ever gotten! The game is suitable for ages 10 and up, making it perfect for family gatherings or game nights with friends. We had so much fun unraveling clues and unlocking secrets with the help of clue cards. Definitely recommend this game to anyone who wants to unleash their inner detective!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Murder Mystery Party Underwood Cellars Interactive Murder Mystery Case File Game for 1 or More Players, Ages 14 and Up

 Murder Mystery Party Underwood Cellars Interactive Murder Mystery Case File Game for 1 or More Players, Ages 14 and Up

1. “I, Alice, recently hosted a Murder Mystery Party using the Underwood Cellars game and let me tell you, it was a night to remember! From the immersive storyline to the realistic evidence provided, my friends and I felt like we were real detectives solving a 20-year-old murder case. We even dressed up in character and had a blast trying to crack the case together. Thanks for making my party one for the books, Murder Mystery Party! Keep up the great work!”

2. “Me, John, and my girlfriend decided to have a cozy night in and try out the Underwood Cellars Murder Mystery game. Let me just say, this game did not disappoint! The attention to detail in every aspect of the game made us feel like we were actually part of the investigation. We spent hours debating motives and analyzing clues until we finally cracked the case like true detectives. Thanks for providing endless entertainment, Murder Mystery Party!”

3. “Hey there, I’m Emily and I’ve been a fan of Murder Mystery Party games since I was 14 (yes, I’m still obsessed at 30). So when I saw the Underwood Cellars game was released, I immediately bought it without hesitation. And let me tell you…it did not disappoint! The storyline is gripping and keeps you on your toes until the very end. Plus, with all the evidence provided, you really feel like you’re part of a real murder investigation. Keep churning out these amazing games, Murder Mystery Party!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a parent, I have observed that children are naturally drawn to mysteries and puzzles. They love the thrill of trying to solve a problem and the satisfaction they get when they finally piece together all the clues. This is why mystery games for kids are necessary.

Firstly, engaging in mystery games helps children develop critical thinking skills. They learn to observe, analyze and make deductions based on evidence presented to them. These skills are essential for their academic success as well as in their daily lives.

Secondly, mystery games also help improve problem-solving abilities. Children are faced with challenges and must use their reasoning skills to find solutions. This encourages them to think outside the box and try different approaches until they reach a solution.

Moreover, playing mystery games also promotes teamwork and communication among children. Most mystery games require players to work together and share information in order to solve the mystery. This teaches children the importance of collaboration and effective communication.

Additionally, mystery games can be educational as well. Many of these games incorporate history, science or math concepts into the storyline, making learning more fun and interactive for children.

Lastly, playing mystery games can be a great way for parents to bond with their kids. It provides an opportunity for quality family time where everyone can participate and have fun together.

In conclusion

My Buying Guide on ‘Mystery Games for Kids’

I have always been a fan of mystery games and I believe they are a great way to keep kids entertained while also stimulating their critical thinking skills. However, with so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. After doing some research and trying out different mystery games with my own kids, I have put together this buying guide to help other parents make an informed decision.

Age Appropriateness

The first thing to consider when buying a mystery game for kids is the age appropriateness. Make sure to check the recommended age range on the game packaging or description. Some games may contain complex puzzles or themes that may not be suitable for younger children. On the other hand, some games may be too easy for older kids and may not hold their interest.

Theme and Storyline

Mystery games come in various themes such as detective, spy, treasure hunt, escape room, etc. It is important to choose a theme that your child will enjoy. Consider their interests and hobbies before making a decision. Kids are more likely to stay engaged in a mystery game if they can relate to the theme and storyline.

Type of Gameplay

Mystery games can be played in different ways such as board games, card games, role-playing games or even through apps on electronic devices. Each type of gameplay offers a unique experience and it is important to choose one that your child will enjoy playing. Board games and card games are great for family game nights while role-playing games can be more immersive for older kids.

Level of Difficulty

It is important to consider the level of difficulty when choosing a mystery game for kids. Some games may have simple puzzles suitable for younger children while others may require advanced problem-solving skills. Look for clues on the game packaging or description about the difficulty level or ask other parents who have played the game before.

Replayability

Some mystery games offer replayability by providing different scenarios or outcomes each time you play. This can add value to your purchase as your child can enjoy playing it multiple times without getting bored. Look for reviews online or ask friends who have played the game before about its replayability factor.

Educational Value

Apart from being entertaining, some mystery games also offer educational value by promoting critical thinking, problem-solving skills, teamwork, and communication among players. If you are looking for a game that can also help your child learn new skills while having fun, make sure to check if it has any educational elements.

Budget

Last but not least, consider your budget when buying a mystery game for kids. They come in various price ranges depending on factors such as brand name, type of gameplay, complexity level etc. Set a budget beforehand and look for options within that range.

I hope this buying guide helps you in choosing the perfect mystery game for your little ones! Remember to involve them in the decision-making process and let them pick out something they will truly enjoy playing.

Author Profile

Avatar
Sophia Martinez
Fueled by her passion for customer engagement and technology, Sophia founded her first startup at the age of 28, a groundbreaking platform that revolutionized loyalty programs in the e-commerce industry. Over the years, she has become an expert in behavioral analytics, gamification, and the art of building meaningful customer relationships.

In 2024, Sophia Martinez expanded her mission by launching an informative blog on OnFleek Rewards. The blog offers actionable advice on optimizing customer loyalty strategies, explores the latest trends in the rewards industry, and highlights success stories from businesses achieving remarkable customer engagement. Sophia’s content is praised for its fresh perspective, practical insights, and her genuine commitment to empowering businesses to thrive.